Citywire printed articles sponsored by:
View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a505955
No 'mortgage time bomb' so buy builders, say analysts
Fears that an interest rate rise could detonate a mortgage time bomb are being overplayed, say analysts, who are almost unanimous on which house builders investors should back: Barratt (BDEV.L), Taylor Wimpey (TW.L) and Galliford Try (GFRD.L).
Markets
Fears that an interest rate rise could detonate a 'mortgage time bomb' are being overplayed, say analysts, who are almost unanimous on which house builders investors should back: Barratt (BDEV.L), Taylor Wimpey (TW.L) and Galliford Try (GFRD.L).
Investors have been concerned about the health of the housing market. This is a reasonable fear, said analysts at Oriel Securities in a note this morning: ‘The fact that mortgage repossessions are rising while mortgage rates continue to fall suggests that there may be a mortgage time bomb waiting to explode when mortgage rates start to rise.’
However, they added that if people aren’t losing jobs then the housing market is relatively safe: ‘Unemployment is a key consideration with respect to repossessions, however we expect unemployment to remain broadly flat over the next 12-18 months before gradually declining. We also note that recent employment data has been better than expected.’
Oriel’s top picks in the sector are Barratt with a 116p target price and Taylor Wimpey with a 38p target price. In fact, with the exception of Bovis (BVS.L) and Bellway (BWY.L), which are both sells, all the house builders come with buy recommendations from Oriel.
Persimmon
Persimmon (PSN.L), which issued a trading statement this morning, is also a buy according to Oriel, though it was not among today's top picks.
Shares in the house builder dropped 0.7% or 3.3p to 488p this morning despite saying that trading conditions had allowed it to improve margins and cashflow.
Of the 17 analysts covering the stock listed by Starmine Professional, 10 give it a buy, five a hold and two say sell. Rachael Waring at Panmure Gordon reiterated her hold recommendation and 505p target price.
Kate Moy at Arbuthnot gave Persimmon a buy with a 515p target price. She said: ‘Persimmon has demonstrated that it is in a strong position to acquire new land and deliver margin restoration, while at the same time significantly reducing debt.’ Oriel also gave it a buy with a 489p target.
However, Robin Hardy at Peel Hunt said sell with a 299p target price: ‘We had expected sales and prices to move ahead but both are down... the lower sales leave a lot to deliver in H2 [the second half of the year]. We remain concerned about the group’s high regional exposure, the high use of shared equity and, in common with its peers, we see inadequate returns.’
Galliford Try
House building and construction group Galliford Try also posted a trading update this morning. According to Waring, the company’s figures today were in line with her expectations – showing total housing completions up 27% and average private sales up 10% – but its shares dropped 1.5% or 8p to 522p on the news.
Waring only has three buy recommendations in the sector and one of them is for Galliford Try with a 577p target. She said it is growing fast while the other firms she likes, Taylor Wimpey with a 47p target and Barratt with a 158p target, are good value because their shares are trading at a significant discount to the assets they own.
Tools from Citywire Money
More about this:
Look up the shares
- Persimmon PLC (PSN.L)
- Galliford Try PLC (GFRD.L)
- Taylor Wimpey PLC (TW.L)
- Barratt Developments Plc (BDEV.L)
- Bovis Homes Group PLC (BVS.L)
- Bellway PLC (BWY.L)
Archive
Today's articles
- Week Ahead: waiting uncomfortably for Greece to go
- Investment trusts beat unit trusts in emerging markets
- Market Blog: confident US consumers lift the mood
- Smart Investor: let the news flow wash over you
- What are investment funds and how do they work?
- Your finances after... marriage
- Lyttleton takes summer break from BlackRock funds
- Threadneedle bond boss Fitzsimmons exits





7 comments so far. Why not have your say?
Jolyon Robinson
Jul 05, 2011 at 21:37
The target prices you highlight for Barratt and Taylor Wimpey are the current share prices. Is that correct?
report thisTony, Wallsend
Jul 06, 2011 at 00:42
#Jolyon Robinson.
You can check current share prices to the right of your comment.
report thisTim Ward
Jul 09, 2011 at 10:27
Its not the threat of an interest rate rise that should be a concern for the builders. At the moment they are all on thin ice and I would avoid buying at all cost.
House prices are falling, we have just had the dead cat bounce and the resumption in falls have continued. Builders can't sell their homes at the moment unless it is on some type of gimmick scheme such as shared equity/ownership, part exchange or to foreign investors like Barratts is doing with the Chinese
Banks won't lend to buyers for these newbuilds the amount the builders want. So as their gimmick schemes run out off money and house prices continue to fall the builders vulnerability will be truly exposed. They are dead men walking. House price falls will force them to revalue their land banks putting them all back into red with their shares spiralling down.
I would avoid builders shares completely.
report thisHugh Stewart-Smith
Jul 09, 2011 at 10:34
the house price index (average house price divided by average earnings) needs to fall to around 3.5 before one should even think about investing in the sector. It's still around 6 - residential property has a long way to fall before the next upturn in the cycle starts - houses are still hugely overpriced in relation to the present and near future economic conditions.
Talking up the market when the HPI has so far to fal is grossly irresponsible and comes only from those with vested interests.
Banks aren't lending because they know the truth - we're still in the downward leg of a well established, and thus predictable, cycle.
It will be at least 5-10 years before I would expect to be investing in property.
And, with regard to commercial property, that too is for suckers. Commercial rents are already falling and will go into free-fall. Valuations will thus tumble.
You'll all find this out on the day that the BOE put up interest rates.
Hugh
(elderly private landlord who has lived through several such cycles)
report thisJonathan
Jul 09, 2011 at 13:27
I saw an offer that the builder would pay the buyer's stamp duty. This is stupid as they actually end up paying more tax. For example a house that is £300,000, the builder offers to pay the 3% stamp duty meaning the total paid for the house is £309,000 including £9,000 stamp duty. If they had offered the buyers a discount of £9,000 on the price the cost of the house would be £291,000 + £8,730 stamp duty. So they just throw away £270 so it makes their houses look like they sell for more.
report thisFranco
Jul 09, 2011 at 14:25
HS Smith above, is the only one who seems to know what he is talking about, except that what he calls house price index is in fact the house price/earnings ratio, the best measure of house affordability. It currently shows that houses are hugely overpriced,
. Note that wealth managers and advisers are as usual divided 50/50 because they are the most ignorant of the lot. Just impostors using trade jargon to conn wealthy fools.
Barratt and Taylor Wimpey are up to their nostrils in debt, they cannot borrow any more and will fail as soon as interest rates rise.. The FAs who recommend buying them are trying to talk the market up to save their own skin and that of their clients whom they had advised to buy just before the housing crush at 8 times current prices.
Make a note of their names and avoid them in future like the plague.
report thisJOHN ROGERS
Jul 09, 2011 at 17:27
Unemployment might be falling in some areas but not the North East as redundancies are announced daily. If the mortgage rate goes up then there will be a rush of repossessions. There are hundreds of new builds in the North East standing empty as there are concerns about redundancies and also lack of mortgages available. It might be OK for an interest rise in London and the Home Counties where property prices are still rising but a disaster for other areas of the UK
report thisleave a comment
Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.