Citywire for Financial Professionals
Stay connected:

Citywire printed articles sponsored by:


View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a434774

Local councils charge taxpayers extra for paying by credit card

Hidden credit card fees can increase the cost of paying by credit card by up to 200%, consumer group Which? has warned.

Local councils are charging people extra to pay council tax, housing rent, car parking fines and dog fouling penalties by credit card, a new report has found.  

Cinemas, airlines and travel companies are renowned for charging people an extra fee to pay by card, but surprising new research from consumer group Which? has revealed at least 55 local authorities implement credit card surcharges too.

The councils surveyed generated over £450,000 from credit card surcharges, although the way the surcharges are applied varies depending on the authority, Which? said.

The highest surcharge was 3% charged by Bath and North East Somerset Council, while seven councils claimed card surcharges had been implemented within the last year.

The cost of paying by card

Paying by card can increase costs by up to 200%, according to Which?

Some retailers will charge consumers a flat fee, starting from around 25p per transaction, but others charge a percentage of the total transaction, which means fees can run into hundreds of pounds. For example, paying for a £19,000 Saga cruise by card would cost £470 in surcharges.

Most retailers claim they are simply passing on the cost of processing the card charged by the banks. However, according to Which? the ‘merchant service fee’ banks charge retailers is typically 0.1p for debit cards and 0.8% for credit cards – far less than the 5% and 3.5% some companies charge.

Peter Vicary-Smith, chief executive of Which?, said: ‘There can be no justification for high card surcharges as all too often they just seem to be an excuse for ramping up costs. While companies may want to recoup merchant fees, these charges need to be fair and transparent, so consumers know the real price before they begin a transaction’.

Which? also pointed out that surcharging is already banned in countries such as Austria, France, Italy, Portugal and Sweden, and limited in countries such as Germany, Denmark and Spain.

To help avoid extra card fees Which? advises consumers to avoid online or telephone bookings, as companies such as Odeon, Vue and Travelodge will not impose card fees on those who pay in person. Which? also reminds consumers to calculate surcharges into the overall cost of a transaction when shopping around and comparing prices.

9 comments so far. Why not have your say?

sam walker

Sep 28, 2010 at 13:03

surely you've got a very big problem if you're paying your council rent/council tax by Credit Card...

report this

Philip

Sep 28, 2010 at 13:12

One thing is for certain if you are going to be ripped off it will be in Britain - we are rapidly becoming a nation who are ripped off at every oportunity nowhere more than by banks.

report this

alan watson

Sep 28, 2010 at 13:19

It wasn't that long ago that credit card surcharges were banned in the UK. Something must have happened in the last few years that has allowed it back in again - rip-off Britain rules again

report this

Bath & North East Somerset Council

Sep 28, 2010 at 13:40

Bath & North East Somerset Council wants as many people as possible to pay for services through methods which are cost effective to the local taxpayer, like Direct Debit, and not encourage payment methods which have a relatively high cost to the public purse, like credit cards. Our Direct Debit collection remains one of the highest in the country and over 70% or our residents choose to pay their Council Tax this way every year.

We are very open and transparent about the purpose behind the credit charges https://secure.bathnes.gov.uk/payments/Section/info/FAQ.asp?id=mop-Card1 and that we make no profit from these - it should be noted that many Council's do not offer a facility for customers to pay bills, like Council Tax, by credit card. We offer an extremely wide range of payment methods and customer feedback on our service is very good. We have received no official complaints about the level of administrative charge.

The exact costs are covered by Commercial agreements with providers so the ranges for the merchant are between 1.5% - 2.5% for credit card payments. We also use a payments service provider to host the payment securely and authorise and bundle the payments together for us which is an additional 1% charge on credit cards. So in total - between 2.5% and 3.5% total additional charge for both Merchant & PSP charges.

The fact of the matter is, that if the Council didn't charge credit card users in order to help cover these costs we would have to find the money from elsewhere through either cuts to services or increases in Council Tax and/ or other service charges. We want people to pay their bills through low cost facilities, like Direct Debit.

report this

Bath & North East Somerset Council

Sep 28, 2010 at 13:41

Please also note there is no credit card surcharge applied to parking fines.

report this

sjg

Sep 28, 2010 at 14:28

Bath and NE Somerset Copuncil like all councils wish to keep the cost to the public as low as possible and so charge credit card fees. However, cost to the public could be kept much lower if Councillors paid their own pensions and did not subsidise it from the Council Tax public purse. Further, the amount of expenses that Counsillors get for site meetings and council meetings could be cut substantially if there was less bureaucracy and more prudent use of the public purse. I would go further even, and merge council wards so that the number of councillors would be reduced. Overall, a great saving to the public purse

report this

Peter J

Sep 28, 2010 at 15:58

Why is Bath & North East Somerset Council posting on this investment website?

report this

Graham Williams

Sep 28, 2010 at 16:33

Why should anyone open their account to a Council who will not reciprocate by allowing the individual to help themselves to anything that said Council may owe them?

What is sauce for the goose should also be sauce for the gander I say. After all it usually takes Councils a long time to pay out anything they owe to individuals, usually a result of overcharging in the first place.

report this

Anthony Lenton

Sep 29, 2010 at 11:13

Sam walker is incorrect in his assumption that paying council tax by CC indicates that the payer has a problem. Most certainly not if a cash back CC is used and there is no surcharge!

report this

leave a comment

Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.

Sorry, this link is not
quite ready yet