Citywire for Financial Professionals
Stay connected:

Citywire printed articles sponsored by:


View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a407233

Equitable victims fear government may seek cut in compensation

The Equitable Members Action Group victims fear that a promised payout by the coalition government for the near collapse of the mutual insurer may be cut to £1 billion from early £4.6 billion estimates.

Equitable Life victims fear that a promised payout by the coalition government for the failure of the mutual society may be cut to £1 billion from early £4.6 billion estimates.  

The Equitable Members Action Group (Emag) believes that a report being produced by Sir John Chadwick will be used to justify a lower pay out from the government. The campaigners have written to MPs after failing to secure assurances from ministers over how compensation was being calculated.  

‘We are deeply disturbed by the gulf between the expectations raised by the government’s promise and what appears to be actually going on at the Treasury,’ said Paul Braithwaite, secretary general of Emag. ‘If the government offers victims 20p in the pound – there will be outrage.’ 

The government should drop the Chadwick report because its assumptions were seriously flawed, said Braithwaite, who called for an independent panel to calculate compensation. 

Braithwaite and his group are pushing for a payout for the £4.6 billion of losses, which was estimated by the Parliamentary Ombudsman in a 2008 report. Equitable victims recognised government finances were under serious pressure and would accept a reduced payout but compensation had to be calculated fairly, said Braithwaite.

3 comments so far. Why not have your say?

Anonymous 1 needed this 'off the record'

Jun 16, 2010 at 15:58

Keep on delaying,commission another report and problem solved as we victims die off .It is akin to encouraging inflation to reduce the debt problem and a game we all recognise as it is as old as the hills

report this

michael price

Jun 17, 2010 at 06:51

when you look back and realise MP's and large % Judge's plus Boot's ALL got out without any penalty poor old Joe Blogs has been kicked into touch "Out of sight -out of mind"

at least this Government is thinking of restoring faith in justice and to be honest any payment has to come from somewhere unknown and is better than nothing under previous slippery regime.

report this

Kristine S-O

Jun 19, 2010 at 02:41

A very Equitable tale ?

A combination of inertia and my financial adviser saved me from a fate worse than death – growing old without enough money to live on - and he did this by telling me what NOT to invest in. Yes, Equitable Life.

I rang him the day I first learned about Equitable Life saying I thought it sounded the best thing since sliced bread – and no middle men, so I would move all my investments over to Equitable Life and would not be needing him anymore. He replied that I should check out their liquid asset ratio first, but I never got round to finding out what he meant by this, or to moving all my investments to Equitable Life.

This happened a good year before anything broke in the press on Equitable Life’s malaise. If HE knew, then why didn’t the authorities know and if they did, were they really powerless to stop the inevitable? If so, then heaven help our new auto enrolled, NEST pension savings !

And another thing - If you loose money because of a delay in receiving what is due to you in the commercial world, you are allowed to charge an interest rate to cover the cost to you of late payment. EMAG savers should be paid interest on compensation that was due in 2001 to help cover the cost of this 10 year delay. It is what Equitable Life investors are missing out on now that needs compensating, not just what went missing due to maladministration.

And another thing - This compensation was not paid to us when it should have been during very good years for the economy. This is not our fault, so there is no reason for government to adjust compensation to allow for the bad current economic conditions.

And another thing - The contention that if Equitable Life had been properly regulated there would have been little difference to the outcome surely proves that the regulations were not even worth the paper they were written on which in itself is justification for compensation?

And another thing - The way full compensation is worked out should not remain a mystery like a with-profits investment. I voted to get Labour out at all costs - even a hung parliament. I voted for “fairness and transparency of government” but in an amazingly short time we have been shown the dark side to this ConLibDem pact – and government practices are already returning to normal.

To get back to my financial adviser – bless his cotton socks - he eventually won £3 million on the lottery and went incognito. He always used to finish his advice sessions with “Of course, you could just put it all on the lottery.” Even doing that could have been a better outcome for those poor Equitable savers.

Kristine S-O

report this

leave a comment

Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.

Tools from Citywire Money

Today's articles

From the Forums

+ Start a new discussion
Sorry, this link is not
quite ready yet