Citywire printed articles sponsored by:
View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a412748
Do councils really only ever fine drivers who endanger children?
Councils are trying to take the moral high ground with car parking penalties when we know many of their practices are highly dubious.
Markets
OK. I'm playing it up a bit.
The press release I just received from the Local Government Association actually said: 'Councils will not apologise for fining drivers who leave their cars in places where they obstruct emergency vehicles or who endanger children on their way to school.'
Fair enough, no one would hold that against them. We've all seen irresponsible drivers parking their cars in clearly dangerous places and most of us would probably be happy to see them clamped. But before the councils can take the moral high ground on this subject they need to tackle the very real grievances by drivers.
Big Brother Watch, part of the Tax Payers' Alliance, says 54 CCTV Smart cars patrolling 31 local council areas in Britain have raised over £8 million in fines for councils in the year to March. CCTV Smart cars have been involved in the punishment of at least 187,993 motorists, they found. Did all those people obstruct emergency vehicles or endanger children? I'm guessing not.
There is clear evidence that pedestrian traffic wardens and private clampers hand out fines in an overzealous manner and charges are often unjustified.
A friend of mine had to work overseas for a couple of months and left his car legally parked. When he came home his car was gone and yellow lines had been painted in the spot where his car had once been. After a number of calls, he found out his car had been lifted and yellow lines had been painted under his car. When he didn't pay the fines - since he was overseas and hadn't seen the stickers accumulating - his car was clamped and eventually taken to a yard. He had accrued thousands of pounds worth of fines. No-one at the council was willing to talk to my friend about the situation or come to an acceptable compromise and since the fines were much higher than the value of the car, he left his car at the compound.
I took my mum shopping in another London borough renowned for its liberal attitude when it comes to distributing parking fines. We were very careful where we parked and bought a parking ticket. Lo and behold, we returned to find one of those yellow stickers on the windscreen.
I'm sure you have many examples, yourselves.
Councils need to address the fact that many fines are handed out to drivers that have done nothing wrong and there needs to be a fairer appeals process. After all, numerous councils have been forced to repay 'illegal' fines and just last month the Daily Mail reported wardens were writing tickets just to meet targets.
I accept that councils suffer as fines go unpaid and that many people do break the rules, but it is also clear that councils rely on the fact that few people will go to court and do nothing to stop innocent drivers being served fines.
Councils need to ensure they have better systems in place before they start sending out irate press releases defending their policies. They definitely need to steer clear of pedalling the clearly ridiculous idea that only dangerous drivers ever get fined.
Tools from Citywire Money
More about this:
What others are saying
Archive
Today's articles
- Overnight Markets: US stocks gain as Europe offsets China concern
- Asset allocation: where bonds fit in to the big picture
- The Expert View: Mothercare, Burberry and Moss Bros
- Friday Papers: Insults fly over troubled HP buyout
- Citywire Top Stocks Daily News Digest
- Market Blog: bargain hunters drive FTSE to strong finish
- Why ‘free’ banking is a dangerous myth
- Chart of the Day: an oil spike threat no longer





6 comments so far. Why not have your say?
Grumpy Old Man
Jul 08, 2010 at 10:30
Deborah,totally agree with you( although not a victim of parking fine mania myself!)
I know it is another subject for another day,but the whole way our councils operate ought to be looked at sooner rather than later, with special regard to value for money,waste,ludicrous jobs,....I could go on.
Thank heavens public sector pensions are being looked at;that is a start.At the same time, perhaps some of the 'tin gods' who rule our councils can be brought down to size .....possibly by Eric Pickles sitting on them.
report thisAnonymous 1 needed this 'off the record'
Jul 08, 2010 at 10:31
Councils need to be put back in there boxes.
Parking rules should be national, in fact pan European i.e. universal & exactly the same where ever you go.
They should go something like - parking charges can only be made under the following rules - only Mondays to Fridays & only 09:00 to 17:00 and only charged at hourly rates with a maximum of 20p per hour. Only police car mounted cameras to be used for speeding.
report thisjames corbett
Jul 08, 2010 at 11:11
Couldn't agree more! No way though that our greedy money grabbing councils will let a cash cow like this disappear, whether it's immoral, illegal or just plain stupid. Anything goes in the need to raise cash these days, and as always the motorist bears the brunt.
report thisjaslek
Jul 08, 2010 at 12:00
well its up to us voters then. at your next local election get appropriate undertakings from prospective councillors or throw them out.
report thisAnonymous 2 needed this 'off the record'
Jul 08, 2010 at 14:44
Anything that gets the council tax down works for me!
report thisRoger Savage
Jul 08, 2010 at 18:20
Anonymous 2 - you're not selfish at all, are you?! Councils used to serve the public, now the public serve the councils. We keep them in their gilt edged pensions whilst they merrily bite the hand the feeds them. Councils and the police are only interested in upholding laws that are happy clappy PC or bring in ££££££, end of. However, I do blame the public for rolling over and accepting all this. If everyone challenged their unreasonable fine, at least it would make it less profitable for them to spread tickets round like confetti.
report thisleave a comment
Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.